Yesterday was my husband’s birthday, and even though he decided to buy his own “big” birthday presents this year, I couldn’t resist putting together a few of his favorite things to spoil him a little – including making him a delicious dessert!
A new leather camera/laptop bag, Hot Buffalo Pretzels, Good Beer, Velvet’s Peanut Butter Buckeye Ice Cream (that I forgot to add in for the picture), and Peanut Butter Pie – what more could a guy ask for?
I was originally inspired to make a peanut butter cream cheese pie after watching a video on Facebook. I didn’t love the recipe though, so I decided to make my own version, which includes a little less cream cheese and a lot more peanut butter! If you LOVE peanut butter, this is the stuff dreams are made of! 🙂 It’s like a peanut butter explosion dancing on your taste buds!
This recipe is super simple, and perfect for the busy SuperMom who wants to make something tasty without spending all day in the kitchen! It’s a perfect dessert to take to Thanksgiving or really, any (peanut-friendly) family gathering because it is quick to throw together but the results are very impressive!

You can stop right here … but why would you want to?
Chopped Reese’s cups make the perfect “crust!”

Yep. Things just got real … real scrumptious!
“Super” Peanut Butter Cream Pie
*One 15oz jar (approx. 2 1/3c) of Natural Creamy Peanut Butter
*16oz Cream Cheese (I used 1/3 fat)
*One 8oz tub of Whipped Topping (Cool Whip)
*2 cups of Powdered Sugar
*1tsp Pure Vanilla Extract
*Prepared Chocolate (or Graham) Crust
*Reese’s Cups and/or Reese’s Pieces to decorate
Mix together peanut butter, cream cheese and whipped topping in stand mixer or by hand. Incorporate vanilla, then slowly add in powdered sugar. Fill prepared Chocolate Crust, and decorate with candies. Chill in refrigerator for at least 4-6 hours before serving (or freeze for 2-3 hours, just be sure to keep an eye on it so it doesn’t freeze solid!).
NOTES: You certainly CAN use “regular” peanut butter (with sugar added), just use less powdered sugar, I would start with 1 cup and go from there.
